Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Coaxial 9x47 Propellor, 3Cell, Benchmark

Here is the first set of results for my coaxial benchmarks.  A little bit of explanation:

The column called "9x47 Coaxial benchmark" are the real test result for 2 motors in coaxial configuration. 
The column called "9x47 Coaxial theoretical" is the sum of 1 x 9x47 pull and 1 x 9x47. I added this column the check the % difference between the coaxial real benchmark results and what theoretical would be possible with 2 coaxial motors if there was no efficiency loss.
The column called "9x47 pull x2" is to compare the difference with 2 pull motors side by side.
The column called "9x47 push x2" is to compare the difference with 2 push motors side by side.

For my Y6 project I need 225 grams of thrust per motor. That is 450grams of thrust per pair. At 450 grams of thrust there is ~9% efficiency loss between the real benchmark and the theoretical value.


thrust

(grams)
9x47 Coaxial benchmark
(watt)
9x47 Coaxial theoretical
(watt)
9x47 pull
  x2
(watt)
9x47 push
x2
(watt)
9x47 Coaxial
Theo-Bench
(%)
50 6,2 5,5 6 5 11,3
100 9,9 10,6 11 10,2 -7,1
150 15,6 15,7 15,8 15,6 -0,6
200 22,2 21,3 21,8 20,8 4,1
250 29,5 27,1 27,8 26,4 8,1
300 37 33,4 34,4 32,4 9,7
350 44,8 40,4 42,4 38,4 9,8
400 53,2 48,6 50 47,2 8,6
450 61,5 55,9 57 54,8 9,1
500 71,1 63,7 65 62,4 10,4
550 79,7 71,5 72,8 70,2 10,3
600 89 80,6 82 79,2 9,4
650 99 89,3 91 87,6 9,8
700 107,1 97,9 100,2 95,6 8,6
750 117 106 108 104 9,4
800 127 116,2 118,6 113,8 8,5
(lower is better)

No comments:

Post a Comment